10 Top Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Companies for 2025

About

Medicare 101

Current Clients

10 Top Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Companies for 2025

By Daniel Petkevich

Jul 14, 2025

A quick overview of 10 Medicare Supplement companies you should consider.

(Listed alphabetically to avoid implying a formal ranking)

Speak with a Medicare Advocate

Talk to one of our Licensed Medicare Agents today to find the right plans for you.

AARP® / UnitedHealthcare

The country’s biggest Medigap issuer, available in all 50 states, backed by an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating, and consistently high customer-satisfaction scores.

Aetna (Accendo / CVS Health)

Part of CVS Health, offers aggressive pricing on standard and high-deductible Plan G, strong enrollment growth, and solid financial strength.

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield

Multiple state affiliates with some of the lowest average Plan G rates in recent quote studies, plus household discounts in many markets.

Bankers Fidelity

A 70-year-old niche carrier with responsive claims service and an A- (Excellent) AM Best rating—often appealing to shoppers who value smaller-company attention.

Blue Cross Blue Shield (other affiliates)

Deep provider networks and, in many states, a “Blue-to-Blue” rule that lets members switch Medigap letters without fresh underwriting.

Cigna

A (Excellent) AM Best rating, nationwide availability, multi-line household discounts, and a 4-star quality score from third-party reviewers.

Humana

Nationwide footprint with member perks such as vision, hearing, and fitness benefits. Premiums can run higher than average, so shop the rate.

ManhattanLife

Founded in 1850, independent, and flexible with health underwriting in some states. AM Best B++ (Good) and trending upward.

Mutual of Omaha

Second-largest Medigap book, up to 12 % household discount, and an industry-low NAIC complaint index—excellent for long-term rate stability.

State Farm

Top-tier customer-service ratings and highly competitive Plan G pricing in recent carrier-comparison research.

How We Chose These Carriers

Market share & stability – the ten listed companies represent roughly two-thirds of all Medigap enrollment.
Financial strength – A- or better AM Best ratings (or improving B++) signal the reserves to keep paying claims.
Customer experience – we analyzed NAIC complaint indexes and third-party reviews.
Plan G availability & pricing – every carrier above offers Plan G, today’s most comprehensive option for new Medicare beneficiaries.

Remember: Medigap benefits are federally standardized—Plan G at one company covers the same gaps as Plan G at another. Price, discounts, underwriting rules, and service reputation are what set carriers apart.

Need Help Comparing?

Our licensed Medicare advocates can pull side-by-side quotes from every major carrier in minutes. Call 888-376-2028 or schedule a time that works for you—no cost, no pressure.

Speak with a Medicare Advocate

Talk to one of our Licensed Medicare Agents today to find the right plans for you.

Your Medicare One-Stop-Shop

Your guide to Medicare Parts A & B, Medicare Advantage, and Medigap. 100% free.

Get the Fair Square Bulletin

Medicare savings tips, helpful guides, and more.

888-454-2383

info@fairsquaremedicare.com

About

Medicare 101

Current Clients

Medicare Supplement Plans

Medicare Advantage Plans

Fair Square 2026

•

Notice of Privacy Practices

Virgil Insurance Agency, LLC (DBA Fair Square Medicare) and www.fairsquaremedicare.com are privately owned and operated by Help Button Inc. Medicare supplement insurance plans are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This is a solicitation of insurance. A licensed agent/producer may contact you. Medicare Supplement insurance is available to those age 65 and older enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B and, in some states, to those under age 65 eligible for Medicare due to disability or End-Stage Renal disease. Virgil Insurance Agency is a licensed and certified representative of Medicare Advantage HMO, HMO SNP, PPO, PPO SNP and PFFS organizations and stand-alone PDP prescription drug plans. Each of the organizations we represent has a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any plan depends on contract renewal. The plans we represent do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, or sex. Plan availability varies by region and state. For a complete list of available plans please contact 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY users should call 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day/7 days a week or consult www.medicare.gov. © 2026 Help Button Inc

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.

MULTIPLAN_FairSquareMedicare_01062022_M

Fair Square Medicare

10 Top Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Companies for 2025

A quick overview of 10 Medicare Supplement companies you should consider.

Speak with a Medicare Advocate

AARP® / UnitedHealthcare

Aetna (Accendo / CVS Health)

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield

Bankers Fidelity

Blue Cross Blue Shield (other affiliates)

Cigna

Humana

ManhattanLife

Mutual of Omaha

State Farm

How We Chose These Carriers

Need Help Comparing?

Speak with a Medicare Advocate

Recommended Articles

More of our articles

Your Medicare One-Stop-Shop

About

Medicare 101

Current Clients

Medicare Supplement Plans

Medicare Advantage Plans